May 2012, Week 4


Options: Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Portside Moderator <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Wed, 23 May 2012 22:14:31 -0400
text/plain (236 lines)
American Airlines Rejects Female Passenger Because Political Pro- 
Choice T-Shirt is "Inappropriate"

by Jodi Jacobson,
Editor in Chief, RH Reality Check

RH Reality Check Reproductive & Social Health and Justice - News,
Analysis & Commentary

May 22, 2012 - article updated at 12:41 pm, May 23rd, 2012.


Yesterday I attended a meeting of pro-choice colleagues working to
ensure women throughout this country get safe, compassionate
abortion care. Today, I received an email from one of those
colleagues, detailing the ordeal through which she was put by
American Airlines on her flights home. They actually forced her to
miss her connecting flight and demanded she change her top. The
reason? Her politically salient pro-choice t-shirt was offensive
to the flight crew.

That sign said: "If I wanted the government in my womb, I'd fuck a
senator."The t-shirt is the now-popularized version of a sign held
by Oklahoma state senator Judy McIntyre (D) at a pro-choice rally
in early March to protest Oklahoma's so-called personhood law,
which in conferring the rights of a living, breathing person on a
fertilized egg denies all rights of personhood of women, full

At the time of the rally, and asked about the sign, State Senator
McIntyre "acknowledged that some in Oklahoma, which is
overwhelmingly Christian, may find her sign's language offensive,
but she wasn't much concerned about them."

"I would hope they would have that same passion about how
offensive it is for the Republican Party of Oklahoma to
ramrod, because they have the votes to do so, bills that
are offensive to women and take away the rights of women,"
she reportedly said.

My colleague, O., of the same mind of many of us in believing that
sign says it all, wore a t-shirt with the same message under her
shawl and boarded an American Airlines flight home from our

So what happened? O. writes:

[O]n the plane of the first leg of my flight home, I spent
the majority of [time] sleeping, using my shawl as a
blanket. Right before we were set to land the flight
attendant from first class approaches me and asks if I had
a connecting flight? We were running a bit behind
schedule, so I figured I was being asked this to be sure I
would make my connecting flight. She then proceeded to
tell me that I needed to speak with the captain before
disembarking the plane and that the shirt I was wearing
was offensive.

The shirt was gray with the wording, "If I wanted the
government in my womb, I'd fuck a senator." I must also
mention that when I boarded the plane, I was one of the
first groups to board (did not pass by many folks). I was
wearing my shawl just loosely around my neck and upon
sitting down in my seat the lady next to me, who was
already seated, praised me for wearing the shirt.

When I was leaving the plane the captain stepped off with
me and told me I should not have been allowed to board the
plane in DC and needed to change before boarding my next
flight. This conversation led to me missing my connecting
flight. I assumed that because I was held up by the
captain, they would have called ahead to let the
connecting flight know I was in route. Well, upon my
hastened arrival at the gate of the connecting flight, it
was discovered that they did indeed call ahead but not to
hold the flight, only to tell them I needed to change my
shirt. I was given a seat on the next flight and told to
change shirts.

Due to the fact that my luggage was checked, changing
shirts without spending money wasn't an option. I
consulted a friend with a law background who told me
covering with my shawl would suffice. Upon boarding the
now rescheduled flight with shawl covering my shirt, my
ticket dinged invalid. I was pulled to the side while the
gentleman entered some codes into the computer and then
told, "it was all good." I did finally arrive home to
pick up my daughter an hour and a half later than

So let's review some facts. O. went through security and was
stopped for additional screening, but not deemed a "security
risk," and no one at TSA made the slightest mention of her t-
shirt. She boarded her first flight, and none of the airline
personnel at the gate mentioned her t-shirt. She quietly took her
seat, wrapped her shawl around herself, and went to sleep.

When her plane landed the flight attendant confronted her and said
she had to speak to the captain. At no point did anyone say
quietly, hey... could you keep that covered with your shawl? Could
you turn it inside out? We have a policy....

Instead, after the plane landed the flight attendant brought her
up front where the captain berated her publicly and made her miss
her connecting flight. It turns out when she asked if anyone had
complained the answer was: NO, Only the flight attendant!

The captain and flight attendant took it upon themselves to call
ahead to the next gate and make them keep her off the next flight,
causing her to miss it. Two American Airlines employees decided
"after the fact" to make an issue of this of their own accord and,
instead of asking discreetly if she could cover her shirt or turn
it inside out, she was humiliated in front of other passengers by
a captain out of control. Yes, in some way this obviously has to
do with profanity, but where does that stop? Is she allowed to
walk into Target? Is she allowed to go to CVS? She was allowed to
walk through the airport... If we women all over this country are
being fucked over, and we can't say that, where does that end?

No.. In this country, you see, fundamentalist right-wing male
legislators in every state can take away your rights. They can
deny you access to contraception, breast exams, Pap smears, and
other primary preventive care. They can deny you access to safe
emergency contraception and safe medication abortion. They can
force any woman in need of a safe abortion to listen to lies about
outcomes of the procedure long disproven by medical science and
public health professionals. They can mandate that you to listen
to religious dogma at crisis pregnancy centers, force you to look
at an ultrasound or hear a heartbeat, make you wait 24-, 36-, 72-
hours before you can get a safe, legal abortion, just because they
feel like it, and just because they feel like it, they can raise
the costs of that abortion -- in terms of travel, childcare,
medical expenses and time -- to really shame you good. Moreover,
they feel empowered to coerce you into procedures like trans-
vaginal ultrasounds, which I maintain is a form of state-sponsored

But protest these laws and the War on Women with a t-shirt that
gets right to the point? Let people know the basis of all of it,
the people that "want government out of our lives" want to place
it directly into our bodies? In a country supposedly founded on
freedom of speech and expression, in which protestors can stand
outside clinics harassing and threatening women and doctors, and
run through every public square with gory doctored photos? A
country in which other protestors can stand outside the funerals
of gay soldiers killed in duty and scream disgusting insults, and
still have their rights protected?

Oh, no. You can't do that. You can't take that message that your
body is your own anywhere. Because in the United States today,
that is like taking your burqha off under the Taliban. That is
"offensive," "insulting" and "not for public consumption."

At least according to American Airlines, which apparently has not
heard the term freedom of expression.

Let's be clear: This is a woman who was not a security risk -- she
got through the gauntlet of DC airport security, which I assure
everyone is easily the most rigorous of any in the country -- and
obviously was not considered a "risk" of any kind, because... she
was not. She boarded her plane without incident and went to sleep.
It was at the end of her flight that the flight crew decided she
should not be able to board the next flight because her t-shirt
was offensive. How is it okay for American Airlines to decide what
she can wear on her t-shirt or not? I have been on flights with
men wearing tatoos that demean women, and t-shirts that advocate
violence against women, that demean women, that treat Obama with
racist derision... What someone wears on their body is their
business. Whether or not you would wear that t-shirt is not the
point. It is not for American Airlines to decide what is
politically okay or not.

In March, State Senator Judy Mcintyre told the Huffington Post:

"I was so excited about the fact that the women in
Oklahoma have finally begun to wake up and fight for their
rights. I saw a sea of signs that caught my eye, but this
one in particular -- I loved its offensive language,
because it's just as offensive for Republicans of Oklahoma
to do what they're doing as it relates to women's bodies.
I don't apologize for it."

We don't apologize for fighting for the freedom of women. We don't
apologize for taking that war into streets, on sidewalks, into
legislatures, into airplanes. We don't apologize for protecting
our rights and our bodies and those of every woman in this

While there are plenty of people in power right now that owe women
of the United States an apology, American Airlines owes a huge --
and public-- apology to O.

Tell them so.

[Jodi L. Jacobson is a long-time leader in the health and
development community and an advocate with extensive experience in
public health, gender equity, human rights, environment and
demographic issues. She is currently Editor-in-Chief of RH Reality
Check. In September 2011, Ms. Jacobson was awarded the "Preserving
Core Values in Science" Award by the Association of Reproductive
Health Professionals.

Previously, Ms. Jacobson was the Director of Advocacy at American
Jewish World Service, where she established a new department,
leading the organization's efforts to mobilize the American Jewish
community toward ending the genocide in Darfur, fighting global
AIDS, ensuring access to quality basic education worldwide,
addressing the global food crisis, and promoting global debt
relief and effective anti-poverty policies, among other issues.

From 1994 to 2007, Jodi served as founder and Executive Director
of the Center for Health and Gender Equity (CHANGE) (est. 1994),
an organization that monitors and seeks to promote accountability
of US international policy to women's reproductive and sexual
health and rights.]


Portside aims to provide material of interest to people
on the left that will help them to interpret the world
and to change it.

Submit via email: [log in to unmask]

Submit via the Web: http://portside.org/submittous3

Frequently asked questions: http://portside.org/faq

Sub/Unsub: http://portside.org/subscribe-and-unsubscribe

Search Portside archives: http://portside.org/archive

Contribute to Portside: https://portside.org/donate